The NYPD trained its officers that the keffiyeh and the watermelon are antisemitic symbols. On September 29th, Mayor Zohran Mamdani released a 33-page Strategy to Combat Antisemitism that names the NYPD as one of its four core partners — five days after that department arrested more than 100 people protesting Benjamin Netanyahu.
I went through every endnote in the report. 49.1% of its citations draw on Zionist-affiliated sources. Nearly a third come from explicit pro-Israel advocacy organizations. And in the section that establishes the threat the entire program responds to, 61.5% of the data comes from just two: the American Jewish Committee and UJA-Federation.
The plan is modeled on Joe Biden's national strategy. J Street praised it. The ADL attacked it anyway. The organizations consulted disagreed only about how Zionist it should be.
This is not a video denying antisemitism in New York. It's a video about what gets counted as antisemitism, who decided, and who ends up on the other end of the enforcement.
SOURCES
"Tackling Hate: The Mamdani Administration's Strategy to Combat Antisemitism," NYC Office of the Mayor, September 2026 — https://nyc.gov/content/dam/nycgov/mayors-office/downloads/pdf/press-releases/2026/2026-09-25-moca-report-interactive-5.pdf
Alex Kane, "Training for NYPD Officers Categorized the Keffiyeh and Watermelon as Antisemitic Symbols," Jewish Currents, April 24, 2025
Politico on the Biden model and J Street NYC's response, September 2026
Jonathan Greenblatt, "It's Time to Admit It: The Left Has an Antisemitism Problem," ADL, July 9, 2021
ADL New York/New Jersey statement on the strategy, September 2026
Shurat HaDin, "Rage Against the Hate" conference, Museum of Jewish Heritage, October 27, 2025
Middle East Eye on Melanie Phillips's remarks at the conference
Hellgate NYC on the NYPD and the West Bank land sale — https://hellgatenyc.com/nypd-shields-illegal-land-sale/
The Forward on Phylisa Wisdom and New York Jewish Agenda
How Zohran Could/Should Arrest Netanyahu
Part 1:
Written, reported and produced by Guy Christensen.
Support our independent work: https://yourfavoriteguy.com/subscribe
CHAPTERS
0:00 Zohran Mamdani Started Funding Zionists
1:48 Zohran Mamdani's Antisemitism Strategy Announcement
3:29 Key Points of Criticism Against Mamdani
4:45 Political Alliances and Business Councils
6:14 Shift from Radical Views to Liberal Zionism
7:15 Analyzing the Anti-Semitism Strategy Document
8:33 Political Connections and Praise from J Street
9:40 Where Is the Funding Going?
11:11 Surveillance and Controversial Museum Trips
13:11 Protecting Synagogues Hosting Illegal Palestinian Land Sales
14:30 Targeting Pro-Palestinian Figures and Activists
15:58 Community Reactions and Criminalizing Anti-Zionism
17:38 Footnotes and Conflating Data in the Report
19:25 Racial Profiling, Surveillance, and Personal Experience with State Pressure
20:09 Personal Consequences of Pro-Palestinian Activism
22:02 The Backfire and Pushback from All Sides
23:21 Rejection from Both Zionists and Supporters
25:24 ADL and J Street Responses
27:32 Broader Political Implications and PR Disaster
28:29 Lack of Focus on Other Forms of Discrimination
30:07 Billionaire Alliances and Missed Economic Sanctions
32:13 Reactions and Smears Following Previous Critiques
33:56 Call to the DSA and Critique of Electoralism
36:07 Systemic Analysis, Class Consciousness, and Support
38:41 Postscript: Radio Call-In and FBI Interrogation Memory
40:17 Personal Experience with FBI Interrogation
